How to Save Money on Garage Door Repair vs. Replacement

garage door repair vs replacement

Garage doors are an essential component of any home, providing both security and value to a property. The garage door keeps the belongings stored within safe from intruders and helps protect against inclement weather, such as extreme cold and high winds.

Like anything else in your home, garage doors are subject to wear and tear over time, leaving homeowners with the difficult decision of whether or not it is worth repairing or replacing their existing door with a new one. So, when is it best to repair a garage door, and when should you choose to replace your existing one?

This post will explore the advantages and disadvantages of both repair and replacement. It will also provide helpful advice on how to save money when it comes to garage door repair or replacement.

Factors to Consider When Deciding Between Repair and Replacement

When it comes to garage door repair vs. replacement, there are several factors you’ll need to consider before making a decision. After all, your garage door is a major investment – and it’s important to get the most out of it.

Damaged garage door

Here are some key factors to consider when deciding between a garage door repair or replacement:

Age of the Garage Door

A garage door should last around 30 years if properly maintained and serviced. However, some doors may need to be replaced sooner as the years go by, especially if exposed to inclement weather or other environmental conditions.

Nevertheless, every garage door has an expiration date. As your door approaches its projected lifespan, repairing it may no longer be the most cost-effective option. While repairs may temporarily extend the life of your garage door, they can only do so much. Eventually, the maintenance and upkeep costs will exceed the price of a new garage door. 

The Extent of Damage or Malfunction

If your garage door is damaged or isn’t working correctly, you’ll need to determine whether the problem is extensive or minor. A minor issue, such as a broken chain or keypad malfunction, can usually be repaired quickly and inexpensively.

On the other hand, if the damage is severe or multiple garage door components are malfunctioning, replacing it may be the best option. Otherwise, you may end up paying 

for a series of patches and fixes that are ultimately more expensive than getting a new door.

If you need clarification on the extent of the damage or if you can repair your garage door, be sure to consult a professional. A qualified technician will be able to assess the condition of your door and determine the best course of action.

Cost of Repair vs. Cost of Replacement

Another factor to consider is the cost of repairing your garage door compared to the cost of replacing it.

Potential Long-Term Savings of Replacement

Replacing your garage door will cost more upfront than a repair, but it can also save you money in the long run. Unless your garage door is still relatively new or the damage is minor, the cost of repairing it may not be worth it.

Not only do you benefit from a new and more reliable door, but you can also take advantage of modern features such as better insulation, stronger locks, and superior weather protection. These features can help reduce your energy bills, improve security, and keep your garage door in better condition for longer.

Repair Options for a Malfunctioning Garage Door

Garage door spring repair

Now, let’s dive into the specifics of getting your garage door professionally repaired. Here’s what you need to know:

Overview of Common Repairs that Can Be Made to a Garage Door

At Safe Way Garage Doors, we offer a wide range of repair services to help keep your garage door functioning properly. Common repairs that can be performed on a garage door include:

Broken Spring Replacement

The springs of a garage door are critical for its operation, as they provide the counterbalancing force needed to lift the weight of your door. If your door is hanging too low or won’t open and close properly, it may be due to a broken spring. You’ll need a service technician to replace the springs and ensure that your garage door is functioning correctly.

Average Service Cost: $180 to $550

Garage Door Opener Repair

If your automatic garage door opener isn’t working, it could be due to a variety of issues. A qualified technician can assess the problem and recommend the most cost-effective repair option. Common issues include frayed wires, faulty circuit boards, and worn-out belts or gears.

Average Service Cost: $100 to $350

Garage Door Cable Replacement

Garage door cables connect the garage door to the opener, and if they become damaged or worn out, it can prevent the door from opening. To replace these cables, you’ll need to call a qualified technician with cable replacement experience. They can also inspect other parts of your garage door system for damage that may be related to the cables.

Average Service Cost: $100 to $400

Panel Repair or Replacement 

If your garage door panels are dented or damaged, they may need to be replaced. In some cases, a skilled technician can repair minor damage, but larger dents or rust will require the panel to be replaced. Most garage door companies will be able to provide you with panel options that are compatible with your existing system.

Average Service Cost: $350 to $1,500 

Pros and Cons of Repairing a Garage Door

Garage door panel repair or replacement

Before deciding whether to repair or replace your garage door, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages of repairing a garage door:


  • Repairs can be completed quickly and with minimal disruption to your daily activities.
  • Repairing a garage door can help extend the life of your garage door.
  • It can be a cost-effective solution, especially when the damage is minor.


  • Repairs are not always permanent solutions, and the same issue may arise again in the future.
  • A repair will not improve the look of your garage door or add other features.
  • The cost of repairs can add up over time, especially if you choose to repair a door that is more than a few years old.

Replacement Options for a Faulty Garage Door

If you decide that repair isn’t the best option for your situation, then replacing your garage door is a great way to get a new and more reliable system. Here’s everything you need to know about garage door replacements:

Garage door opener replacement

Overview of the Process of Replacing a Garage Door

A professional installation service can help you replace your old garage door with a new one. Here’s how the process typically works:

Step 1: Choose Your Door

The first step is to decide which type of garage door you want. You’ll need to consider materials, size, insulation, and other features such as windows or decorative hardware. Most companies will offer professional advice and guidance to help you select the best door for your needs.

Step 2: Installation

Once you’ve chosen your door, a qualified technician will come to your home and install it. This typically takes several hours and requires special tools, so it’s important to hire a professional who has experience with garage door installation.

Step 3: Final Touches

Once the door is installed, your technician will ensure it’s properly aligned and leveled. They will also add any necessary hardware, such as hinges and handles. This is an important step to ensure that the door operates smoothly and safely.

Average Cost of a Replacement: $500 to $4,700 (Depending on size and material)

Pros and Cons of Replacing a Garage Door

Replacing your garage door is a big decision, so it’s critical to consider all of the pros and cons before making a final decision. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages of replacing a garage door:


  • A new door can improve the look of your home.
  • A new garage door will be more reliable and durable than an older one.
  • You can choose from a range of materials, sizes, insulation options, and features such as windows or decorative hardware.


  • Replacing your garage door is a big investment, and it can be costly.
  • You’ll need to hire a professional who has experience with garage door installation.
  • The process of getting a new garage door can be time-consuming.

How to Decide Between Repairing and Replacing Your Garage Door

Deciding between repairing and replacing your garage door can be a difficult decision. The best way to determine which option is right for you is to consider the age of your door, the severity of the damage, and your budget.

If your garage door is more than a few years old and the damage is extensive, then replacing it is likely your best option. On the other hand, if your door is relatively new and the damage is minimal, then repairing it can be a cost-effective solution.

No matter which route you take, make sure to consult with a professional garage technician who can offer advice and guidance before making a final decision. With the right information, you’ll be able to choose the best option for your situation.


Now, let’s look at some commonly asked questions people have about repairing and replacing their garage doors:

The Wrap Up

As you can see, there’s a lot to consider when it comes to deciding between repairing or replacing your garage door. Be sure to weigh all of your options carefully and consult with a professional who can offer advice and guidance before making a final decision. With the right information, you’ll be able to make an informed choice that’s best for your needs, budget, and lifestyle.

At Safe Way Garage Doors, our team of experienced technicians can help you determine the best course of action for your garage door issue. Whether you need a minor repair or a full replacement, we have the expertise and knowledge to get the job done right.

Contact us today to learn more about our services and to get a free estimate. We look forward to helping you with all of your garage door needs!